The Battle for Wesnoth Forums

I'm open to adding another scenario if need-be, but I feel that adding a whole Eldred-focused scenario might be a bit too much of a tangent. Though I do agree that Eldred really needs more characterization before his betrayal; particularly his relationship with both Garard and Asheviere. How would y...

Nah, it took me a couple of tries. First try I aimed for 100+ finishing gold, which I decided wasn't going to be doable. Second try I waited too long to go after Asheviere, and didn't make it in time. Third time's the charm!

UPDATE - I'm working on version 2.0 of TDG. Feedback thread here: viewtopic.php?t=58257

Victory, glorious victory! And with 74 gold left in the bank

Hello all! I'm working on a version 2.0 of TDG, taking into account the excellent feedback that you've all provided on both the forums and discord. (I've temporarily taken TDG off the add-on server while I prepare the new version) My story goals are: - make Garard less of a caricature, particularly ...

Uh oh, that's not good! Easy is supposed to be E-A-S-Y, especially for an experienced player. Thanks for letting me know this scenario is too hard - I'll need to change difficulty (and probably pretty drastically too). If you'd like to post a start-of-scenario save, I'd be happy to play through and ...

Campaign maker here - just want to say that I've read all your feedback and I really appreciate all the time you've put into playing and reviewing EI! If there's anything specific you'd like changed for 1.20, let me know and I'll see what I can do.

Very nice! Note that the Mari "Female Captain" unit is missing her left arm - that probably should have been put in the original post! She does indeed wield a sword, and does wear armor without a helmet. The unit can be found in Yumi's "The South Guard, Revised" add-on, on the 1....

Not getting caught on minor details also doesn't mean we shouldn't strive to make it more logically consistent. I think you also haven't gotten my point that the majority of the interactions are optional. I wouldn't have an issue with optional interactions that flesh out Deoran and co. My concern i...

I'm not necessarily trying to push my particular version, but you did ask multiple times for suggestions, particularly in the discord, no? I do worry we might be getting a little hung up on minor bits of the Wesnoth world. In my experience, players tend to care most about a compelling story with int...

I agree with you both about Sir Gerrick's sacrifice - it's a lot less meaningful when he hasn't been with the player. I'm not sure a great solution here. Do any of you have suggestions? Some of my concerns are: Gerrick and Mari fill very similar story roles, as "generic military adviser guy&quo...

If it were entirely up to me, in an attempt to appeal to both veterans and newbies, perhaps the tutorial/TSG would look something like this? I've tried to keep core characters and scenarios, while still limiting the complexity the player gets exposed to. This is purely my suggestion; not trying to f...

I certainly don't want Delfador or Kaylan to feel like a villian, and I was aiming for closer to "flawed" for Garard, not "idiot". Will be working on some dialogue revisions to try and improve things; thanks for the feedback! 2) The revised EI uses story elements from DM, most ob...

There's a spot to the northeast of Dacyn's starting location to which you can move Dacyn and wall him off with Gweddry and Owaec, in a way that makes it impossible for the orcs to attack him. That should keep him safe while the rest of your prisoners break out.

Alternatively, put a real village on the tile and use PLACE_IMAGE to cover it up with your desired variation